McAfee (MX Logic) Appriver Proofpoint Mimecast Symantec (MessageLabs)
mcafee logo-appriver logo-proofpoint logo-mimecast logo-symantec
Email Protection and Continuity SecureTide Email Filtering Beginner Package Email Security Email Safeguard .cloud
Gartner Magic Quadrent Gartner Visionary Quadrant Not rated by Gartner Gartner Leaders Quadrant Gartner Vivisionary Quadrent Gartners Challenger Quadrant
Anti-Virus Proprietary engines Eset, Avira, AhnLabs F-Secure, McAfee, proprietary engines 3rd party engines Proprietary engines
Spam Filtering Proprietary engine plus 3rd part RBL Proprietary engine plus proprietary RBL Proprietary engine plus proprietary RBL Proprietary engines,  plus 3rd part RBL Proprietary engines, plus 3rd part RBL
DOS/DHA Yes Add on Yes Yes Yes
Challenge Response No No No No No
Grey Mail Yes No Bulk Mail Filters No Yes
Content Filtering Yes Outbound Only Flexible DLP options Yes Yes with preloaded dictionaries
Outbound Filtering Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Regular Expressions Add on No Yes No No
Link Protection Yes No Add on  Yes No
Attachment Filtering Can be filtered by extension, mime type and size Extension only Can be filters by extension and mime type Can be filters by extension and mime type Can be filtered by extension, mime type and size
Image Scanning No No No No Yes
Country Blocking No Yes Yes Yes No
End User Quarantine Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Admin Quarantine Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Admin White/Black Lists Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
End User White/Black Lists Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Custom Notifications Yes No Yes for groups Yes No
Message Spooling 60 days 30 days 30 days 30 days 5 days
Message Continuity Yes Add on (30 rolling days) Yes, also has Message Replay as add on Yes, with Outlook integration as add on Add on (30 rolling days)
Global Threat Center Yes 24 hour threat center 24 hour threat center 24 hour threat center Threat center on 3 continents
Email Encryption Add on Add on Add on Add on Add on
Supports TLS Yes Opportunistic Yes Yes Add on
Email Archiving Add on Add on Add on Add on Add on
Console Overview Tab dependent control organization is often inconsistent Clean console some reduced functionality Tab dependent control console can be cluttered  Policy Drive with GUI is older and functionality is often burred
Set up Fee No Yes No No No
User Creation Individual, Bulk, LDAP Individual, Bulk, LDAP Individual, Bulk, LDAP Individual, Bulk, LDAP Individual, Bulk, LDAP
LDAP Populating users and passwords Populating users Populating users Populating users Populating users and passwords
Auto Account Creation Populates user after 8 valid emails in 24 hour period No Populating user thresholds configureable No No
SQR Configurable Time No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Adjustable Spam Settings No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Domain Validation No No No Yes Yes
Group Admin Yes No Yes Yes Yes
Individual Setting No Yes Yes No No
Outbound Disclaimers One global disclaimer can be implemented Yes Customizable down to the user level Yes Yes
Time customization quarantine report No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Multi SQR per Day No Yes Yes Yes No
Reporting 20 preloaded reports by console or email Portal Downloadable and portal Portal Fully customized reports by email and portal
Social Media Account Protection No No Add on No No
Spam Reporting Via email or Outlook plugin Via email Yes via admin portal Outlook plugin Yes
False Positive Reporting Via email No Yes via admin portal Outlook plugin Yes
Provisioning Time Frame Less than 1 hour Less than 1 hour Less than 1 hour 24 hours Less than 1 hour assuming txt validation is in place
Trail 30 day money back guarantee 30 days 30 days Yes 30 day money back guarantee
Monthly Terms Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes